Justia Utilities Law Opinion Summaries

Articles Posted in Washington Supreme Court
by
A group of organizations and individuals challenged the constitutionality of a statewide initiative approved by Washington voters in November 2024. The initiative, known as I-2066, enacted broad changes to energy regulation, including requirements for utilities and local governments to ensure natural gas access, restrictions on local air quality regulators, removal of zero-emission goals from state law, amendments to the Decarbonization Act, and limitations on the state building code council’s authority regarding gas usage and transitions away from fossil fuels.The King County Superior Court reviewed the case following cross-motions for summary judgment by the parties. The court declared I-2066 unconstitutional in its entirety, finding that it violated three constitutional requirements: it impermissibly encompassed more than one subject, failed to include its subjects in the title, and failed to set forth the laws it amended. This judgment was appealed directly to the Supreme Court of the State of Washington.The Supreme Court of the State of Washington reviewed the superior court’s ruling de novo. The court held that I-2066 violated the single-subject requirement of article II, section 19 of the Washington Constitution. It found that the initiative combined several distinct subjects with separate regulatory effects, lacking the necessary rational unity among its provisions. The court concluded that the provisions introducing distinct subjects were not severable and thus rendered the entire initiative unconstitutional. The Supreme Court affirmed the superior court’s judgment on the narrower ground of the single-subject violation and did not address the other constitutional arguments raised. View "Climate Sols. v. State" on Justia Law

by
This case involved a dispute over control of sewerage service to Point Wells, located just north of the King County, Washington border, within the boundaries of Snohomish County and Olympic View Water and Sewer District (Olympic). The issue presented for the Washington Supreme Court's review was a determination of the effect of a 1985 superior court order which purported to annex the Point Wells service area from King County to Ronald Wastewater District (Ronald). Resolution of this issue required interpretation of former Title 56 RCW (1985) and former RCW 36.94.410-.440 (1985) to determine whether the 1985 court had authority to approve the transfer and annexation. The trial court held that the 1985 Order annexed Point Wells to Ronald. The Court of Appeals reversed, holding that King County could not transfer annexation rights that it did not have. Finding no reversible error in the appellate court's conclusion, the Supreme Court affirmed. View "Ronald Wastewater Dist. v. Olympic View Water& Sewer Dist." on Justia Law

by
King County, Washington enacted a first-of-its-kind ordinance that required electric, gas, water and sewer utilities to pay for the right to use the county's rights-of-way (franchise). The associated planned charge was called "franchise compensation," and was based on an estimate of a franchise's value. If the county and utility couldn't agree on an amount, the county barred the utility from using its rights-of-way. The issue presented for the Washington Supreme Court's review centered on the County's authority to collect franchise compensation. Secondarily, the issue was whether water-sewer districts or private utilities could use the rights-of-way without a franchise from the County. The superior court ruled King County lacked authority to collect franchise compensation. The Supreme Court reversed, holding that generally, King County could collect franchise compensation. Water-sewer districts and private utilities had no general right to use King County's rights-of-way without a franchise. View "King County v. King County Water Dists." on Justia Law